Top 3 Wine Clubs in Napa/Sonoma – Best Picks By Millennials

budbreaklizThe 40 Millennial students in WineBiz Class 305W at SSU were asked to analyze wine clubs in the Napa/Sonoma area and to select their top three favorites.  Criteria were based on best practices in wine clubs and included the following:


1)     Number of different club levels – at least 2 choices is preferable

2)     Price ranges for each level – a variety of ranges is preferable from low to high

3)     Shipping frequency – every 2 to 3 months is better, because lowers cost or discounted shipping

4)     Club level by varietal preference e,g. red wine, white, sparkling, etc.

5)     % discount for additional purchases

6)     Number of benefits for being a club member, e.g. discounts, events, personal concierge, etc

7)     Types of special events – the more unique and interesting, the better…

8)     Anniversary gifts for staying in club a year or more

9)     Anything else special or unique about the club

We were provided a list of 30 wineries by the SSU Wine Business Program.  The 30 wineries had been nominated by the founders of the program – of which there are more than 200.  Therefore, the 30 wineries were nominated by their peers as having excellent wine clubs.

In order to analyze the 30 wine clubs, the 40 students in the class were divided into teams and each team was asked to research 3 to 4 wine clubs and complete an evaluation form using the criteria above.  Each team reviewed the results and selected a winning wine club to send to the sweepstakes round.


We then put the top winery from each team on the board — according to criteria — so we had 8 wine clubs in the sweepstakes round.  One student from each team presented the wine club components, and then the whole class was asked to vote on their top 3 preferences.  This resulted in the following awards:


1st Place Wine Club – Mumm’s (


2nd Place Wine Club = Benziger (


3rd Place Wine Club = tie with Rodney Strong ( and St. Supery ( both receiving equal votes


The Millennial students appeared to like the wineries that had multiple levels with a range of pricing from inexpensive to expensive.  For example Mumm’s basic level is only $45 for 3 bottles of wine every 2 months.  Another important criterion was the type of events offered.  The more creative the event, the more votes it received.  For example, Mumm has a lobster tasting where they pour whole cooked lobsters on a long table and everyone gets to dive in and drink with sparkling wine.  St. Supery lets club members have first chance at a private box at a Giant’s game, etc.


Bus 305W would like to congratulate this year’s winners of the Top 3 Wine Clubs of Napa/Sonoma.


7 thoughts on “Top 3 Wine Clubs in Napa/Sonoma – Best Picks By Millennials

  1. Mumm Napa Winery: 3 facebook fans

    Benziger: 437 facebook fans

    Rodney Strong: 72 facebook fans

    St. Supery Winery: no facebook page

    Are any students interacting with the wine clubs through their facebook pages?

  2. Pingback: Where to golf in Napa valley? | World Golf Systems

  3. Tina, that’s great that you have over 1,000 people in your facebook group, but groups don’t appear in the facebook news feed like pages do. Groups are more for groups of people who get together, like the SSU Wine Club. Pages are for products and services, like wineries.

    Facebook just made these changes recently to their pages, but now you can add apps and do other things that makes it important for companies to use pages and not groups on facebook.

  4. Pingback: Napa Wine Club

  5. hello — I see nothing in criteria about QUALITY of wine? Maybe something using average tasting score across accepted methods?
    A cheap wine club with fun events does not replace good wine. I see the wine as the focus — vs the “extras”.
    Example: unsure if some of Sonoma/Napa’s best wineries have wine clubs. The wineries that are rated highest, have wine clubs, and offer club price points are of utmost interest regardless of whether they have FB page.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s